$419,900list price
Price cut$25,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,058 sq ft House
232 SW CARTER AVE, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34983
Listing courtesy of Lena Johnson Real Estate Inc. MLS# A12072358.On the MLS · Listed Aug 15
$419,900
386 SW DONNA TER, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34984
3 beds2 baths1,970 sq ftHouseBuilt 2005
Updated today, November 3, 2026This home against Bayshore Heights
$213 per sq ft, 12% under the Bayshore Heights median
22 days on the market
Price cut $5,100 since it was listed at $425,000
$2,862 in property taxes (2025)
10,019 sq ft lot
2 car garage
Bayshore Heights today: 36 homes for sale, median list price $419,900.
About this home
For sale by owner, now cooperating with buyer agents! One-of-a-kind custom-built home in sought-after Bayshore Heights with a BRAND NEW ROOF (April 2026). This 2005 builder's model, lovingly cared for by one owner, features an entertainer's kitchen with maple cabinetry and 2" granite countertops. Primary suite offers his-and-hers walk-in closets, separate shower, and soaking tub. Oversized screened patio overlooks a mango tree and manicured landscaping. Abundant natural light from 17 windows and 3 oversized sliders, plus 12' tray ceilings, crown molding, and custom built-ins. City water/sewer, irrigation on private well, stainless appliances (2022), AC (2017), extremely low homeowner's insurance, and less than 1 mile from the Turnpike. Pristine condition and exceptional quality.
Near this home
Elementary school: Bayshore Elementary School, 0.5 mi
Middle school: Southport Middle School, 3.7 mi
High school: St. Lucie West Centennial High, 1.6 mi
Park: macedo park bench, 0.7 mi
Grocery: Winn-Dixie, 1 mi
Distances from the center of Bayshore Heights, PORT ST LUCIE. Schools are nearest by distance, not an attendance zone.
Listing courtesy of Pure Equity Realty LLC. MLS# B26087666.
Listing information is provided by the MLS and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Listed October 12, 2026.
Similar homes near Bayshore Heights, PORT ST LUCIE
5 photos$419,900list price
Per sq ft$239
4 bd · 2 ba · 1,756 sq ft House
367 SW GRIMALDO TER, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34984
Listing courtesy of Reliant Realty ERA Powered. MLS# B26035986.On the MLS · Listed Jun 1
5 photos$415,000list price
Price cut$59,152
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,540 sq ft House
2049 SW BAYSHORE BLVD, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34984
Listing courtesy of Adams Homes Realty Inc. MLS# R11137575.On the MLS · Listed Nov 2
5 photos$429,900list price
Per sq ft$297
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,446 sq ft House
402 SW SEAFLOWER, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34984
Listing courtesy of American Realty of PSL LLC. MLS# B26073999.On the MLS · Listed Sep 8
$429,900list price
Price cut$4,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,560 sq ft House
2098 SW BURLINGTON ST, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34984
Listing courtesy of Dominion Realty Group. MLS# A12079203.On the MLS · Listed Aug 25
$439,900list price
Per sq ft$247
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,784 sq ft House
1661 SW NORMAN LN, PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34984
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Masterpiece Realty. MLS# B26094806.On the MLS · Listed Oct 29