5 photos$1,700,000list price
Per sq ft$316
5 bd · 3.5 ba · 5,387 sq ft House
4560 S 25TH ST, FORT PIERCE, FL 34981
Listing courtesy of Casabella Miami Realty. MLS# B26082424.On the MLS · Listed Sep 29
$1,689,888
1578 THUMB POINT DR, FORT PIERCE, FL 34949
5 beds6 baths3,146 sq ftHouseBuilt 1970
Updated today, November 3, 2026This home against Fort Pierce
$537 per sq ft, 147% over the Fort Pierce median
41 days on the market
$23,000 in property taxes (2025)
26,136 sq ft lot
Private pool
Fort Pierce today: 420 homes for sale, median list price $320,000.
About this home
LISTED BELOW APPRAISAL PRICE!! WELCOME TO YOUR OWN ISLAND RESORT! Discover a rare Fort Pierce retreat featuring TWO residences on approximately .60 acres just moments from the Atlantic Ocean. Offering approximately 3,146SF under air & over 4,400SF total with 5BR & 6BA, this exceptional property combines the main “Island Oasis” (2330SF) residence with a separate private “Coastal Cottage”(816SF), ideal for guests, extended family or income opportunities. Live the Florida lifestyle with your own saltwater pool, pickleball court, lush tropical setting & convenient beach access, all surrounded by boating, fishing & waterfront lifestyle that makes Thumb Point so special. For the investor, this property offers a compelling story: gross rental income from Air B&B, with strong 2026 performance. For the lifestyle buyer, it delivers something increasingly difficult to find-privacy, flexibility, multiple residences & a true resort atmosphere. Come discover your own piece of paradise at Thumb Point
Near this home
Elementary school: Lawnwood Elementary School, 0.3 mi
Middle school: Dan McCarty Middle School, 0.6 mi
High school: Fort Pierce Central High School, 2.5 mi
Park: John B Sports Complex, 0.1 mi
Grocery: Publix, 0.9 mi
Distances from the center of FORT PIERCE. Schools are nearest by distance, not an attendance zone.
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Select Group. MLS# M20056942.
Listing information is provided by the MLS and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Listed September 23, 2026.
Similar homes near FORT PIERCE
5 photos
5 photos$1,995,000list price
Per sq ft$768
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,597 sq ft House
1714 COCONUT DR, FORT PIERCE, FL 34949
Listing courtesy of LAER Realty Partners Bowen/Wellington. MLS# R11163956.On the MLS · Listed Feb 14
5 photos$1,750,000list price
Price cut$249,000
0 ba · 7,488 sq ft 2 to 4 units
951 KING ORANGE DR, FORT PIERCE, FL 34982
Listing courtesy of Realty 100. MLS# F10555883.On the MLS · Listed Mar 1
5 photos$1,200,000list price
Per sq ft$398
4 bd · 4 ba · 3,017 sq ft House
1606 THUMB POINT DR, FORT PIERCE, FL 34949
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty of PSL. MLS# B26055426.On the MLS · Listed Aug 13
5 photos$1,150,000list price
Per sq ft$401
4 bd · 3.5 ba · 2,868 sq ft House
1718 RIO VISTA DR, FORT PIERCE, FL 34949
Listing courtesy of The Keyes Company. MLS# B26081735.On the MLS · Listed Sep 28
$1,400,000list price
Per sq ft$341
0 ba · 4,111 sq ft 2 to 4 units
600 S OCEAN DR, FORT PIERCE, FL 34949
Listing courtesy of The Keyes Company. MLS# B26095924.On the MLS · Listed Nov 2